 |
|
The only tank the Germans had...according to books - Printable Version +- Forums (https://www.theblitz.club/message_boards) +-- Forum: The Parade Ground (https://www.theblitz.club/message_boards/forumdisplay.php?fid=2) +--- Forum: General Discussions (https://www.theblitz.club/message_boards/forumdisplay.php?fid=86) +--- Thread: The only tank the Germans had...according to books (/showthread.php?tid=65224) |
The only tank the Germans had...according to books - Weasel - 10-28-2013 I am sure we have all read books where the allied author states that "we were faced by several tigers" but I am re-reading a book "Tank Rider" and according to the author no matter what tank they faced it was a tiger. In one incident "we were faced by 13 tigers" and another "several tigers drove up to the woods". I believe that the author faced over 100 tigers so far and I am only 70% done with the book. It really is true that to the allied soldier every German tank was a tiger isn't it. RE: The only tank the Germans had...according to books - Ricky B - 10-28-2013 And every shell was fired by an 88. RE: The only tank the Germans had...according to books - Weasel - 10-29-2013 Yes, that too. Perhaps if the Germans had concentrated on only 88s and Tigers things may have been different. Logistics wise it would have been fantastic. RE: The only tank the Germans had...according to books - Outlaw Josey Wales - 10-30-2013 The three book set about the 101st AB for Normandy, Holland and Bastogne by Koskimaki is the same way. RE: The only tank the Germans had...according to books - Weasel - 10-30-2013 (10-30-2013, 01:26 AM)Outlaw Josey Wales Wrote: The three book set about the 101st AB for Normandy, Holland and Bastogne by Koskimaki is the same way. Did you read the three part book series by Donald Burgette, excellent stuff. I will have to look for the other. RE: The only tank the Germans had...according to books - Toblakai - 11-04-2013 (10-28-2013, 06:07 AM)Weasel Wrote: I am sure we have all read books where the allied author states that "we were faced by several tigers" but I am re-reading a book "Tank Rider" and according to the author no matter what tank they faced it was a tiger. In one incident "we were faced by 13 tigers" and another "several tigers drove up to the woods". I believe that the author faced over 100 tigers so far and I am only 70% done with the book. I read that the allied (often?) confused a Panzer IV with a Tiger. Maybe that’s one of the reasons and I think that eyewitness reports need always a critical view 
RE: The only tank the Germans had...according to books - -72- - 11-15-2013 Fwiw, Burgette had 4 books (although I have only read Currahee so far). Also along those lines, there was a book written during the war - I forgot the exact title, but it was about the Battle of Coral Sea (and had been republished by Bantam in the late 70's), and the author was seeing Me-109's everywhere. It must have been a similar sort of thing ... when under severe threat you fall back to whatever fits -after all there is a big difference in being shot at by something as opposed to sifting through model boxes at the local hobby shop I guess. RE: The only tank the Germans had...according to books - Weasel - 11-16-2013 I own the first three: Currahee, Road to Arnhem and Seven roads to hell, they are all excellent and worth the $. Well the Japanese did model one of their planes after the HE-100, but not the 109!! Amazon has the books by Koskimaki! RE: The only tank the Germans had...according to books - Pewpewchewchew - 02-01-2014 (11-04-2013, 10:51 PM)Toblakai Wrote:(10-28-2013, 06:07 AM)Weasel Wrote: I am sure we have all read books where the allied author states that "we were faced by several tigers" but I am re-reading a book "Tank Rider" and according to the author no matter what tank they faced it was a tiger. In one incident "we were faced by 13 tigers" and another "several tigers drove up to the woods". I believe that the author faced over 100 tigers so far and I am only 70% done with the book. To be fair, they do look pretty similar front the front especially when visibility is limited. RE: The only tank the Germans had...according to books - Weasel - 02-04-2014 I think being attacked by a tiger is more "glamorous" than saying a stug, plus it is easier to remember. And I remember one tanker saying that when attacked by German tanks they all seemed to be Tigers. |
){kind=link}