HPS Kursk '43: Prokhorovka: The Historical Battle - Printable Version

HPS Kursk '43: Prokhorovka: The Historical Battle - Printable Version

+- Forums (https://www.theblitz.club/message_boards)
+-- Forum: The Firing Line (https://www.theblitz.club/message_boards/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: Tiller Operational Campaigns (https://www.theblitz.club/message_boards/forumdisplay.php?fid=11)
+---- Forum: TOC Mod Scenario List (https://www.theblitz.club/message_boards/forumdisplay.php?fid=107)
+----- Forum: Kursk 43 Mods (https://www.theblitz.club/message_boards/forumdisplay.php?fid=113)
+----- Thread: HPS Kursk '43: Prokhorovka: The Historical Battle (/showthread.php?tid=71292)

HPS Kursk '43: Prokhorovka: The Historical Battle - Crossroads - 12-21-2017

Commanders, on behalf of Alan Arvold I am happy to upload his Kursk'43 scenario Prokhorovka: The Historical Battle to Blizt Scenario database. I don't have the game my self, unfortunately, so any errors in the scenario information please let me know and I'll fix them.

Here's the scenario description by Alan:

Quote:Prokhorovka: The Historical Battle, by Alan R. Arvold

Prokhorovka: This is the historical battle of Prokhorovka based on Christopher Lawrence's book "Kursk: The Battle of Prokhorovka", which is considered to be the definitive and most modern information source on that engagement. It is also based on the Historical Prokhorovka scenario in the video game East Front of the John Tiller's Campaign System, which itself is also based on the book. This scenario only lasts one day.

Note: Design Notes by Alan included in the download.

The scenario has been created with HPS version of the game.

The scenario is available at Blitz Scenario Database: >> HERE <<

RE: HPS Kursk '43: Prokhorovka: The Historical Battle - Crossroads - 12-21-2017

Here's the scenario Design Note by Alan, also available in the download zip:

DESIGN NOTES FOR KURSK: PROKHOROVKA
By Alan R. Arvold

Kursk: Prokhorovka is a one-day scenario depicting the actual critical battle of Prokhorovka. The
scenario is based on Prokhorovka: The Historical Scenario, a scenario in the John Tillers Campaign
Series Module; East Front. While the Campaign Series depicts battles on the tactical level, the Panzer
Campaigns depict them on the organizational level. While there are already Prokhorovka scenarios in
Kursk '43, these last about three or four days and almost never end in the classical armored
engagement. At least with this scenario, one will have a reasonable facsimile of the classical battle.

Mapboard

The mapboard was easy to do. I just cordoned off an area that corresponded to the area of the
Campaign Series scenario. I then deleted the eastern six kilometers of the mapsheet as this area is never
used in the scenario in either game. This made the map more compact.

Orders of Battle

The orders of battle were patterned after the ones in the Campaign Series scenario. I had to create
some additional support units for the German units. These were Infantry Guns (both 75mm and
150mm), 50mm Anti-Tank Guns, and SS Grenadier Motorcycle units. I only used the support weapons
that were at regimental level. Those support weapons that were organic to the battalions are presumed
to be divided up among the line companies and thus are not shown. One SS German grenadier battalion
in the Totenkopf Division (3 rd Battalion, 6 th SS Panzer Grenadier Regiment) was still mounted on
motorcycles, so I made them into motorcycle battalions. On the Russian side I changed the anti-aircraft
companies in the mechanized and motorized brigades. The game uses 37mm anti-aircraft guns for these
units but this is not accurate. In truth, these were heavy machine gun units, usually 12.7mm. So I
changed those units to those. Also the artillery battalions in those battalions were actually 76.2mm
Infantry Guns, not the regular 76.2mm field guns. I changed those too. Naturally there were no unit
pictures for any of those units in the game, so I had to borrow some pictures from other games in the
Panzer Campaigns Series. I included those unit pictures in files in the Zip-file.

Scenario

The scenario set-up is based on that of the Campaign Series version. While most units are in the same
locations in both scenarios, there are a few units in the HPS version that were one hex away from their
true location, usually due to the size of the hexes and the stacking limitations. I have the same units
fixed in place in both scenarios. The release times for the units in the HPS version, because of the two-
hour turns, may get released a little earlier or later than they do in the Campaign Series version. These
unit fixes are to keep the units in place until their historical time of release. But the HPS version has a
problem in that fixed units can be released if they are spotted by an enemy unit. This means that units
may be released much sooner as visibility increases during the day. On Turn 1 this is not a problem as it
is the Dawn turn and the visibility is one hex. But on Turn 2 the visibility goes up to two hexes and
units in the front line see each other, which at the very least results in massive artillery exchanges
between the units and attacks by companies who would not normally attack because of their weak
strength. Of course, I am talking about AI controlled units here. A human player can keep his units
from doing stupid things. (But then, the Russians had this fetish about constantly attacking and
counterattacking so these attacks by weak units are not so out of character with them.)

There are few units that are at 100% strength in this scenario, even on the German side. While both
sides had taken considerable casualties up to this point, the Germans kept their units close to full
strength by tapping their support units for excess personnel. However, by the 12 th of July, this source of
replacements was running out and few of their previously wounded had returned to duty. The Russians
of course have several major units that have been in battle for several days and are at much reduced
strength. One would think that the units of the 5 th Guards and 5 th Guards Tank Armies would be at full
strength. However, both armies suffered from stragglers and vehicle breakdowns during the long road
march to Prokhorovka and these would not catch up until after the battle.

I have played this scenario several times against the AI and can say that while it gives me a
Prokhorovka-like battle, each battle is never the same. Against a human opponent the battle is more like
history with some minor differences.

Conclusion

I hope this scenario gives the players a unique look at the historical battle of Prokhorovka. Anyway, I
hope that players will enjoy it.

RE: HPS Kursk '43: Prokhorovka: The Historical Battle - Crossroads - 01-06-2018

There's a new revision to Kursk scenario by Alan. Please download again for the latest version.

Quote:I am sending you updated files for my Prokhorovka V scenario in East Front and my Prokhorovka scenario in Kursk '43. Both contain the same corrections. The Russian 136th Guards Rifle Regiment has been moved from its old set up area in the 2nd Tank Corps to the defense line in front of the 18th Tank Corps with its sister regiment from the 42nd Guards Rifle Division. Its seems that according to recent new sources, including Christopher Lawrence's book, that the 136th Guards Rifle Regiment was not moved to the 2nd Tank Corps area until the 14th of July. It seems that the old sources that I used when I made my first Prokhorovka scenario 15 years ago were incorrect when they said that said the 136th was with the 2nd Tank Corps on the 12th. My guess this was due to translation errors when translating Russian documents into English.

I always thought that the 2nd Tank Corps looked a little strong with the attachments of the 53rd and 55th Guards Tank Regiments and the 136th Guards Rifle Regiment to its structure, certainly string enough to attack the 1st SS Panzergrenadier Regiment of the LAH division in the game. Yet Rotmistrov considered it too weak to attack on the 12th and only had some of its support units support the 2nd Guards Tank Corps assault on Das Reich. The 53rd and 55th Guards tank Regiments were only attached to the 2nd Tank Corps as a reserve in case the Germans attacked and broke through the 2nd Tank Corps thin front line. They were not allowed to attack. As it were they were already part of Group Trufanov and when that group finally moved south in the early afternoon of the 12th, those two tank regiments also moved out. Any way on the 14th, Das Reich was the only division attacking and that was to the east. Both the 183rd Rifle Division and the 2nd Guards Tank Corps had to stretch their defensive lines to the south to contain Das Reich and that meant the 2nd Tank Corps had to stretch its line too. As it was still too weak, Rotmistrov decided to reinforce it with the 136th Guards Rifle Regiment which moved over during the night of 13/14 July.

I also made some corrections to the attached artillery regiments in the 5th Guards Tank Army. I finally got all the designations and compositions correct, again using the more recent sources as my guide.

RE: HPS Kursk '43: Prokhorovka: The Historical Battle - Crossroads - 01-20-2018

+1, with some further adjustments to Soviet Orders of Battles and their positioning on map.

RE: HPS Kursk '43: Prokhorovka: The Historical Battle - Crossroads - 02-06-2018

+1, with updates to Design notes document as well.