Closed thread rules

[Von Luck]

Granted its up to the custodians to close a thread when they feel it has gone on long enough etc.Example one reply in the Matrix debate in my opinion was a bit to much but i cant put up my thoughts on that thread.Ok if a certain member gets offensive etc block him/her not the thread.Were here to play were here to give opinions and views etc on what we want dont want etc.As far as im aware members are entightled to put up a fair reply comment etc.I wont go into detail but there are more than one on my next bit barring a member for being honest etc is a bit much.Way out of line fair enough you might want to read some of the messages a bit more clearly before you make desisions if this means im barred for posting this so be it.

[Hawk Kriegsman]

Hello All,

I am new at this business and this is the first board issue I have had to deal with without my mentor's (Ed) assistance.

I felt that shutting it down was the best course of action as the discussion was going nowhere.

I hear you John and will look to moderate the poster in the future.

Thanx!

[Big Dawg]

Hawk,

My wife was giving me a ear full today.

I sure could have used you to "shut it down"! ;)

Keep up the good work.

[K K Rossokolski]

Jack...I am sure you deserved it.

O/T A little snow in Canberra earlier, first for 3 or 4 years.

[Herr Straße Laufer]

Hi John, Thanks for your comments.
Here is the forum rule:
_________________________________________________

Rule #20

Message Boards are moderated by club leadership with discussions concerning historical and game issues relating to each individual ladder. While we respect free speech, we reserve the right to edit or delete messages which we determine to be inappropriate.

Please refrain from personal attacks, ie namecalling, or cursing on the message boards. Debate can become heated, but lets keep the flaming to a minimum so that we can have reasoned and impassioned discussion.

As with our gaming ladders, the related message boards are moderated by the Ladder Commanders and their Assistants. In all issues relating to message board content their word is final. If you have further issues with the board moderation contact the club senior officers.
__________________________________


It does state that the Ladder Commander has the power to edit or delete any posts. That does include the right to lock something down if a debate gets more than "heated".
Some may disagree with how hot the "heat" is? Or, what impassioned means?
Some may feel that repetion, though tedious to read, is not "inappropriate"? Others may think it is?
What is definately an infraction is cursing on the forum or picking out a member for specific "treatment". You can argue the post but you cannot call a poster names or tell them to shut the :censored: up. That would be a clear violation of forum rules?

In my time as an officer I locked threads and sent e-mail or PM's to members to explain why it was done. Often that was enough to get members back on track. Other times I would edit the offensive part of the posts and leave them so the member would come back to see the "edit".

Hawk was placed into a tough spot as the Ladder Commander and I believe he took the proper actions in closing the thread down. I might have been able to say this sooner but, I was tied up and could not post. :smoke:

Tide1 will be able to fill his shoes and implement the rules where needed.
Everybody just needs to calm down and realize we are discussing a game amongst a group of friends? Different friends have different ideas.
Some friends may get tedious but you never have to shoot them? ;)

[zeiss]

Some friends may get tedious but you never have to shoot them? ;)

Yes.. if they think that Squad Leader is better than ASL. ;)