Major Dick Winters discussion.

Thread Modes

Major Dick Winters discussion.

06-17-2006, 06:48 AM,

Steel God

General

Posts: 4,904
Joined: Sep 1999

RE: Major Dick Winters discussion.

I am a big fan of Dick Winters, more so after reading Band of Brothers (and I dislike Ambrose as an historian). But in my opinion the actions at Brecort Manor do not warrant the Medal of Honor because his actions did not meet the criteria:

"for conspicuous gallantry and intrepidity at the risk of life, above and beyond the call of duty, in actual combat against an armed enemy force."

Meaning Dick Winters was no more conspicious at Brecort than any other participant, and none of his actions placed him at greater risk than anyone else involved. The fact that he commanded there is acknowledged by the DSC as opposed to the awards given to others, but MoH status, I'd have trouble swallowing myself.

Paul

PS: A bit of trivia, the medal is not really called the Congressional Medal of Honor. It is the Medal of Honor. It is usually awarded by the President on behalf of the Congress, and that's why it's ended up being caled the CMH.