If you test this way don't test at all

[McIvan]

Perhaps what is needed are guidelines for testers, similar to what Huib outlined, maybe included with each H2H scenario download to heighten the chance that they will actually be read, as well as on the H2H section.

Btw Montana Mud, I don't think Huib just wants a certainl clique of reviewers at all. He just wants reviewers to focus on particular aspects and realise that as he designs historical scenarios, the forces and terrain often can't changed. Reviewers who don't appreciate that are, inadvertently, missing the point of what they are supposed to review. Which is why the reviewer guidelines might be helpful.