Which counts more ...

[majog]

Just a note to both Zeiss and Panther. Obviously Hawk and others are reading these postings. While everyone has a opinion and is entitled to have rightly have one, what may ultimately result from this debate is not about this game but a perception of you as an opponent and if they might want to continue to play you again in the future. As the tourney host it is within my power to issue a ruling but I feel that since we are all adults here, that disputes are best resolved between the opponents if at all possible. I believe that I gave my opinion as the scn designer of the complexity of this scn and why I designed it the way I did. I also believe the Zeiss was more than fair in offering a compromise. Panther brought this to the forum to hear different perspectives and received numerous opinions. What he works out with Zeiss is a choice between the 2 of them unless they cannot reach agreement then it falls to me as the host. I do not believe it is in their best interest to insert ourselves into that choice but rather just judge their discussion and action and decide from there whether we deem them a worthy opponent in the future.

Just my 2 cents.