Scenarios

[Bluto]

That is not an easy question to answer! I myself only have three of the HPS games, Atlanta, Chickamauga, and Gettysburg. I have not played any of them enough to really say which is better than the other. I imagine an interest in a particular campaign of the ACW would have as much to do with rating a particular game higher than the others. I myself am a fan of the battle of Chickamauga, so I am biased towards that particular game, all the more so as it includes the battle of Stone river, another favorite of mine. If we were all Bill Gates we could solve the problem by just buying everything! I have not done so, but I believe an analysis of the scenario data base would be useful to see which game holds the highest rated scenarios. Hope this helps and see you on the Great Redoubt!