Scenarios

[Bluto]

I actually prefer the Matrix reissue of John Tiller's original Battleground series for the ACW over the newer HPS Campaign series. While they are in many respects identical, and some good ideas were incorporated in the HPS games, I still rate the old Battleground games more enjoyable. However, to switch eras, I prefer the HPS Napoleonic Campaign games over the older Battleground games. I would say that the older BG Napoleonic games probably illustrate the formalism of the era better than the HPS versions, but as a gamer I prefer the greater flexibility of the HPS games. Hope this helps!

James