Chuck10mtn Wrote:Oh my GOD, here we go again.Who started this thread he should be court marshaled. I know that the xtreme assult isn't perfect but it is a far cry better than the old automatic surround, disrupt, capture. As someone earlier said I think that when you have one group rushing to assult another a lot more losses should be taken on both sides. If the losses were greater for the attacker win or lose it wouldn't be such a big offensive stratagy. I have a hard time seeing how the game takes longer, its still only X number of turns. I believe the exteme assult is closer to reality than the old assult rules were. Just my opinion on the subject.
Chuck
Cuck,
I am not saying that I want to remain with version 1.02 assault disrupt and overrun. And, some do find that just as realistic "within the scale and concept of the game" as others who see version 1.04 as "realistic".
I think 1.04 can balance an unbalanced scenario. But, that makes the point that the Extreme Assault rule changes the game dramatically.
If, like me, a player thinks that Extreme Assault slows the game down and is unrealistic, why do we have to accept it?
What about making a simple formula to create a "mild" option. Something inbetween?
I'm sure that the code exists and could be easily plugged into an update. Hell, it could even be offered as a "mod" if they wanted to.
Forcing the use of Extreme Assault is not the way to go. But, it seems that it is the way they want to go?
I'm glad someone brought this up and so many others are making their opinions public.
RR
Ed,
xtreme assult, I would like to see maybe 3/4 of what it is now any easier would in my opinion make it too easy to become a way of battle. I think it was used as a last resort for taking a position of importance. People here have gotten use to the old tatic of S D C (Surround, Disrupt, and Capture )and are having a hard time adjusting how to play. I'm not saying its right or wrong, just changed the way you or people in general have to approach the battle now.I never got the hang of S D C so to me its not a big deal.With regards to the Issue of Xtreme assult, I would like to see how the different sides feel about their total strategy. How often they use assult when attacking.What percent of thier attacks are assult. How do they assult. Assult 1st, Use Arty then assult, Surround, Disrupt ,Assult. But more than that I have a hard time buying that 90 guys can rush a dug in infantry unit and after all is said and done everybody goes back to thier origional spot with no causalities.
Archived Forums
Help
Calendar
Member List
Search
){kind=link}
