Aachen west wall anyone want to try it out.

[Herr Straße Laufer]

LOL Guys its a game dont forget i only want someone to try it out.Alfons suggest to the designer a better map or where he might have gone wrong.As for the units entering where etc maybe intended that way no idea.All im asking for is somebody to play it with me with me as the Axis.Faults we can find from that ok.Im already playing a large scenario by the designer of this one and yes there are gliches in the one im playing but minor ones which can be sorted but we have to test them to get it right.Im no historian but Aachen was a brutal battle i belief as it was the first German town to FALL might i add to the Allied push.Nobody's perfect when it comes to designing scenarios so please give a little leeway to those who try and give us more.PS as im part of the H2H section no nasty remarks about desingers just hints and help for the designer please.

John, I beg to differ with a couple of your remarks. This is what Huib wrote:

Alfons de Palfons Wrote:
"No wonder. The map is terrible. It is easy to call your scn historical, but there is a bit more to it to really get it that way. However a map is something that everybody can do right with some effort.
This can never pass as historical scenario. No need to even play it to see that."

The implications are clear. I see it as another in a line of non productive and condescending comments from this member. :chin:

If Dan would write in his description, "historical based" would that have been better? Or, are we going to be crushed under the avalanche of designers who want "realism" down to the birds on the tree branches being from the local region?
I hope more PBEM'ers are doing it for fun, and skills challenge, more than seeing if a town is precisely positioned, with all the roads having the proper width and length, under trees that are locally grown?

Huib's comments are not fire in a fireworks factory but, they do have more heat than light? :smoke:
I think it is more the "tone thing" that adds "bash" to what he writes?

Hopefully someone will step up to test this scenario? And, they are not scared away by the comments.
I'd take up your offer but, I have to decline. I already think that games longer than 30 turns are way too big.



RR