So You Want Quality CS H2H Scenarios?

[Glint]

Hi Mike,

I do see where you are coming from, a good concept true, and agreed.
Perhaps the h2h section could be where designers wish to obtain comments about their' scenarios in a bid to improve their' skills. Nothing wrong with that providing you have enough support from playtesters.

''So, your idea Peter, would be to collect game information and ratings from players at the conclusion of a scenario - currently some voluntary information is shared - correct? Then would designers go back and make revisions to their designs - kind of like a work in progress?'' -(Mike)

Spot on Mike. The database hopefully, could provide space for feedback once played and reported, as I said, one could be unable to report a game unless both players have filled in the report.
Regards whether a designer would then go back and revise the scenario would remain to be seen. Perhaps another utility could be, run the database like a football league, (British, not American, lol) where, every now and then, scenarios that have not been played a certain number of times get relegated from the database, a way of removing the deadwood perhaps?
That way large scenarios could be introduced as well which, as re another post from HSL, would not be feasible to be playtested in h2h.

Just putting this together off the top of my head, as I wish to be constructive in this thread, - not just criticising without offering possible solutions!

All the best,
Peter