re: scenario design

[Glint]

KK and HSL, - I could respond but let's just say this, -

'' Glint Wrote: If I design a scenario and play test it, it needs to be downloaded to record a game surely, or that's the way my mind sees it. The games were up for sometime in the database and never played.


HSL Quote - ''First time I have seen this.
Most designers simply put their scenarios in the dBASE to be played. There are no points given for uploading scenarios, unless they go through H2H. My point was that you get to report a game that no one else gets to report. Simply because you were testing a scenario?''

If I playtest a scenario with someone and we don't get bonus points as in H2H, then at least the result should be reported and points awarded out of respect for the time dedicated to such playtest. The scenario needs uploading to report a result does it not? If then it is decided that the scenario needs modifications, what is the point of leaving it in the database for others to play? I think in the past that you have argued for the database to be cleared out of the 'dross' that are unplayed so give me credit for keeping my scenarios private until I am happy with them and thus keeping the database 'uncluttered' ?