RS Sorrow on Saipan - Design Notes

[Huib Versloot]

Hmm, if I counted well all testreports but one (of the player with the lowest ELO) show a US win. I fear this will continue when it's available on the ladder with so minor changes. Time will tell.
The high ratings in most testreports on this scenario are absurd. Not saying that it isn't a fun and promising scenario, but IMO you can't give high ratings until a scn is perceived as balanced.
At least that is what I thought was the purpose of H2H; to have a section where you could download scenarios that are approved for Human versus human on balance.
Personally I've always said that you can only use statistics to see if a scn is balanced and not opinions and therefore the H2H section seems to add little to improve the number of balanced scenarios out there.
I've had it with one of my own scenarios. In the H2H everybody said it was great, later on the ladder one side won all the time. I then adjusted it.

Huib