France '14 Historical outcome

[jonnymacbrown]

Here is the final tally n the 158 turn played by myself and Tom Quinn:



The French had 650,000 men and 3000 guns.
BEF= 35,000 230 guns

The Germans had 836,000 men and 3,600 guns.

Using the new data, would this have been a loss for the French? jonny