What's the consensus?

[Liquid_Sky]

Its hard to say. Seems that the most popular game is always the newest one. At the moment Moscow '42 is the one receiving the most 'talk'.

I have them all, end yet there are some I have never played.

The most enjoyable ones have been Normandy, Budapest, Stalingrad, Tunisia.

I have played Kharkov 42, Market Garden, France and Sicily...they were okay.

I didn't like Bulge, but I know others love that one. I recently played a scenario from Sealion, and it was a wild one. I will probably play a campaign of that some time soon. A lot of the other ones I have only played a scenario or two at most...and some I have never played at all, like El Alamein, Tobruk, Smolensk, Kursk, Rzhev, Kharkov 43 and Salerno

So I guess it comes down to personal preference, and perhaps even to what books you have read on what battles. Or if you like Grand Offensives like Minsk/Stalingrad/Normandy, or go for the more personal battles of Tunisia....

Really, I think if you buy something that interests you, you will probably find somebody here who will play it.