CMRT: tank combat seems way off

[A Canadian Cat]

An interesting thesis.
If it is correct, the commander's ability to spot, depending on the equipment of the tank, seems to be weighted to low in certain situations.

BFC concluded that the hull crew had to much weight (same difference in the end - except turning down the ability of the hull crew will not give tanks more spotting ability while turning up the commander's ability would). Post #55 here http://www.battlefront.com/community/sho...?p=1492444 (also post #107 and #114)

it should work that more eyeballs produces better results. Just like being buttoned or unbuttoned should have an affect, as should moving or stationary. The question should be if the driver/radio operator are contributing too much to the overall spotting picture not if they should be factored out completely. I'm wondering if the internal weights favor information from the driver/radio operator more than they perhaps should.