(03-06-2015, 03:48 PM)Toblakai Wrote: ...If you have the time and motivation it would be interesting how elite and high leadership infantry units would fight behind bocages against attacking units with fire support from mortars and tanks.
.....Maybe a CM Beta Tester is willing to explain us how the black box of Combat Mission does work ...
We can be pretty sure that Elite/high leadership units perform better than lower quality ones in general small-arms combat so there's no real need for tests to prove it.
I tend to concentrate my tests on aspects of the game that I'm not sure about, and usually just one test run is enough to confirm what I already suspected..:)
We can also be sure that Elite/high leadership units won't have any benefit if they're taking a tremendous overwhelming pounding from tanks and artillery and bombing, they'll be hurt just as bad as lower-qual units.
Field Marshall von Kluge said the same thing in a letter to Hitler dated July 22nd 1944 as German units took a terrible hammering from the air in Normandy-
"The psychological effect of such a mass of bombs coming down with all the power of elemental nature upon the fighting troops, especially the infantry, is a factor which must be given serious consideration.
It is immaterial whether such a bomb-carpet catches good troops or bad, they are more or less annihilated" (von Kluge quoted in 'The Struggle for Europe' by Chester Wilmot, page 364)
As regards CMx2 game mechanics a good thing to remember is that the units usually behave just like real humans, so treat 'em right and they'll love you to bits..:)
"Regard your soldiers as your children, and they will follow you into the deepest valleys.
Look on them as your own beloved sons, and they will stand by you even unto death!"- Sun Tzu, 600 BC