EP '14 mechanics/balance

[Strela]

Volcano Man;

1. I do like the variable VPs idea from the TWIE series, and it would be nice to have them in FWWC for situations like Namur, and rewarding the Germans for going for it quickly. If I can get that added to the series then it would make it practical to provide "bonus" VPs for early capture of Namur, Maubeuge, and things like that. It wouldn't be necessary, but it would be a nice improvement.





Of interest there is a number of Tiller games where 'by turn' or variable VP's are in game (think asymetric in Squad Battles).

We are canvassing John to include by turn VP's as an option for at least the next Panzer Battles game after Normandy and would have dearly loved it in Normandy.

The reason we believe they are worthwhile is it removes the last turn syndrome. Currently, the only player who scores points is the one who holds the hex when the game ends. A valiant defense till end - 1 is ignored.

If available it will open up so many more possibilities for game play. 

Do I hold that forward defensive position for as long as possible because I get large points for every turn I delay the enemy - the points I get outweigh the cost of the units to hold it. Do I rush ahead ignoring my flanks because that objective deep in the enemy rear is worth so many points each turn? I may ultimately get beaten off it, but if I hold it for a sufficient time it is more than worth the effort and will confound the enemy who has to react to stop me racking up points instead of holding back the slow grind.

We have even suggested a VP value for both sides. A particular hex maybe more valuable to the defender than the attacker and the defender will be rewarded more for each turn he holds the hex. The attacker may get 0 points for taking the victory location but he has to take it to deny the defender racking up those points.

This concept, coupled with the 'new feature' coming with the next release of Panzer Battles will make some of the most interesting situations possible.

If we get this right there is no reason why it can't go into other series and make the players decisions much more relevant based upon an evolving situation rather than the 'I have 24 turns to go and capture point X' - grind, grind, grind. 

David