Is this game supposed to be realistic ?

[-72-]

What I think I hear you saying Andy is that it would be better to have a new thread.

Really my point was that there is a difference between the title, Renaissance and the engine for the Musket and Pike series. I took the OP's comments to be about a combat model, and there are more than a few ways it can be tackled within the engine.

The scenarios in Renaissance would be dictated as much by the points awarded in the OOB file per unit (that isn't the engine that set those values -but rather the scenario designer) -but anyway, if the point was maybe using a new topic for a discussion is better than using one where some guy shows up, makes 2 posts and pffft disappears -is a better way to go, then I will take that on board.