Atheory's Project: Operation What if Calais 1944

[ComradeP]

Are you sure you selected Alternative Assault Resolution and not Optional Assault Results?

I don't know what the HA values are for infantry in your intended scenario, but with Alternative Assault Resolution they will only use their HA value when assaulting hard targets. It seems very unlikely assaulting pillboxes is easy with that in place, unless the defenders all have E or F morale and immediately disrupt.

Also: there's no difference between a unit with 8 out of 8 guns and 8 out of 12 guns, as for units not composed of men, no pdt effectiveness modifier is applied aside from unit quality, range modifier , terrain/strongpoint firepower bonus or penalty and elevation so the fire values should be the same.