Renaissance Optional Rules: Best 4 historical accuracy

[JuanModesto]

I prefer NME ON myself as it can lead to blitz tactics and unrealistically high losses.

Thank you very much for your feedback, Agmoss99!

So your proposal is that "No Melee eliminations" leads to more realistic and historical accurate results than "Partial Retreats", isn't it?

I guessed that a group of warriors being overwhelmed with no rout to scape would flod neighbouring units. But given that this option could even not be available at all, the expected result should be an stiff last resistance. Any case, sudden and complete elimination seems not realistic and as you say, may lead to gamey tactics.


Thank you for you advise!

Juan

(sorry for my late response)