Napoleonic Battles - Optional Rules Guide 1.4(4.06)

[The_General]

I fully agree with Devoncop.

MTD is horrible - I played with it in Wellington's PW and it had far more negative effect on French C/D quality units than on British A/B. It was almost impossible to do anything good in close proximity to redcoats.
As for No Detached Melee - at first glance it is logical but in practice it can lead to a comical situation like surrounding enemy unit with detached cavalry which can't do any harm to the enemy.
To me both rules are definitely OFF.

Here is my recommended set of optional rules for PBEM games.