Wolfpack or Midway

[Gary McClellan]

Honestly, they are both pretty different than Guad.

Midway focuses on Air Ops (as you would expect) so your real issue is going to be "search and strike". Where is the enemy? How do I get at them? Then, you are really fighting against time. Hanger and Deck ops take time. If you don't make use of your time well, you're liable to get unwelcome guests with full decks.

Wolfpack puts much more depth into the sub engine that is in Guadalcanal. You really need to pay attention to not getting spotted (or heard!) and setting up your shot. Or, you may need to focus on figuring out where that sub is, and at minimum, keeping its nose down until your convoy is clear (you can play as either side.)

Really, I think they're both worthwhile (of course, I am very slightly biased), and it kind of depends on which one interests you more from first causes.