Scheldt '44 - Realism versus Playability?

[Outlaw Josey Wales]

Technically, the only historical accuracy is at the start of the game.  Everything after that is what you choose to do.  Cdr's didn't get replays to watch.  You have an advantage already, if you choose to use it.  I don't.  The more time I spend on replays, the less time I spend on playing and I would much rather play than watch videos.  I got EFII in Dec 94 and haven't watched replays since sometime in 95.  Personally, I think replays should be an optional rule.

Replays are an option, since it always asks you if you want to watch or not... 

That is not what I am saying.  Right now, you could choose not to, but, your opp can.  In reality, Cdrs don't get replays before deciding what to do.  As an optional rule like I am talking about, is both players can watch or both players cannot watch.  It's just another way to play.