Just to hopefully invoke discussion

[Mr Grumpy]

Well I am open to ideas like this (just my personal view), but these informal guidelines would only catch a certain percentage of reports from players who a) know about the guidelines and b) are happy to abide by them, we would still never actually know if the results reported were "completed" games (>25% of turns) or ones that fell under the <25% completed turns guideline? 

If we had the admin resource we could check a game file from each reported game, but even if we could get a file from all the games the resource does not exist to check them all.