Just to hopefully invoke discussion

[Green]

There is no need to check files. Players can be trusted and anyway both would have to agree to ignore the rules, which makes it less likely.

The guidelines could be mentioned in your "How to join the TOC ladder and info on active/inactive status" sticky thread. At least some people would see it there. Since only one player needs to be aware of it, they could refer their opponent to the thread when the issue of reporting a game arises. This information would soon spread through most of the community.

Some would not be aware of it and some would ignore it. But if it improves the average quality of reporting, the fact that it is not universally adopted is no reason not to implement it. So if something could be decided upon and the solution was posted in this thread and in your sticky, that should be enough to get the message out.

Not sure how something like this is decided. Wait a week or so to allow everyone to make suggestions? Have a poll?