JTS Gettysburg pdt bug

[logruspattern]

To put things in perspective, this is about 2 guns.  2 guns which in the battle (iirc) were set up on Oak Hill - a fair distance away from anything. Personally I would think any Confederate player would have more problems than worrying about setting up Whitworths in areas that might become close range.

Hence why I said it was an edge case.

I doubt I'd even call it a bug, but it seems rather more like a ratings disagreement.

I disagree. A ratings disagreement would be the difference between the artillery firepower in the different titles. Take the Napoleon in Gettysburg and Overland1 respectively, for example:

N 1 14 2 11 3 7 4 5 6 3 8 2 10 1 13 .5 -1
N 1 20 2 14 3 8 4 6 6 5 8 3 10 1.5 13 .75 -1

Now the Whitworth; the difference is even more stark with firepower differences of an order of magnitude in many range bands:

W 2 0 14 3 21 2 28 .75 35 .25 70 .2 -1
W 1 15 14 12 21 10 28 8 35 6 70 4 -1

Combined with the facts that it is the only weapon entry that begins with the range '2' instead of 1 in the Gettysburg pdt and any other game pdt that I've seen, and that even indirect fire weapons do not have minimum ranges, I maintain it is a bug.