VOTE: Best Scenario Voiting!!!

[Mr. Guberman]

Do we want to have the 3 best scens...of CS?

...or EF?

...or WF?

...or RS?

...it seems very few play RS...less play WF than EF...

...if not each, apiece...this is a, rather, non starter...

Cheers
Curt

[Herr Straße Laufer]

There are votes for RS scenarios Curt.
I did not vote for one because I rarely play RS.

What is more fair, voting for what you know or voting because you have to?
If Valor reviews his vote parameters and wants us to vote for one of each then we can go back and edit our votes?

If RS scenarios are rarely played that would be reflected in the voting, under the parameters we have now?
It's not a reflection on scenario designers or designs? It's more what players like to play?

Ed

[Mr. Guberman]

Ed,

Agreed.

Was just wondering if this was a "fanzine" vote or a vote for "best" scens.

I usually play WF and EF more than RS, too.

Cheers

Curt

[Herr Straße Laufer]

Curt, I understand. :smoke:
If you look at the one's I voted for they are stock from the early Talonsoft days. Not even sure what the designers are doing these days.
I even do not like some of the scenarios I've seen voted on here, in this thread.
I could vote for some of my own but, they've not been vetted or stood the test of time. :rolleyes:
Half are in need of upgrading with the release of version 1.04 and the incompatablility to the Blitz project disk. The other half need updating due to the experience I've had designing more/new scenarios. I've gone back to my first ever design and I am reworking it. :)
I'm going to take a walk through each design in turn and correct problems while updating to version 1.04.

Maybe we could do another thread with all three/four included?



Ed

[Filthy-Missile]

1. Storm 555
2. Hurricane on Biak
3. Tank Graveyard at Minsk

[Jeepster777]

My votes are:

1) RS Race to Monywa

2) EF Giants on the Vistula

3) EF **Schwedt


Cheers,

Eddie
Jeepster777

[SGT Rice]

1. Playing With the Death's Head - EF
2. Thunder Valley - EF
3. Hugh is Coming - WF

[Yossarian]

My top three votes:

1) RS......Trapped on Timor

2) DGVN.. Battle for Black Virgin Mountain

3) WF......The Beginning of the End, U.S. in Torch

:smoke:
Mike

[Otto von Blotto]

Hausser's Last Charge EF
Giants on the Vistula EF
Into Battle Again WF

[umbro]

Hmmm, my favourite scenario?

1) The one I am playing right now! That feeling that can only be generated when going up against a Sicilian when death is on the line.

2) H2H (I mean the real thing, online, where the men are separated from the sheep), "A Small Bridge" is really good (as long as you get the first couple of turns sussed as the allies)

3) Any large (i.e. size 8+), historical (i.e. accurate), where the good guys (i.e. the Allies), can make history (i.e. change the course of the war), I am a sucker for.

umbro