0619_01s: The Tobruk Stakes and the Race for Alamein_Alt - PzC 11 El Alamein '42
2 - 1 - 3
Rating: | 7.29 (7) |
Games Played: | 6 |
SM: | 7 |
Turns: | 160 |
Type: | Custom |
First Side: | Axis |
Second Side: | British |
Near Tobruk, June 19th 1942: After winning "The Gazala Gallop" Rommel was faced with a situation very much like the one he was in at this time in the previous year. The 8th Army was in retreat to the Egyptian frontier leaving a sizable force garrisoning Tobruk. Rommel knew he could not sustain a deep drive toward Cairo and the Nile without first securing his lines of communication. This meant capturing Tobruk, a prize that eluded him in 1941, and using the port as a basis for supplying a drive to the east. So with 8th Army in retreat and his weary panzers hot on their heels, Rommel disengaged his army, turned and attacked Tobruk in a run one author called the "Tobruk Stakes". The fortress fell in a single day's fight in what was a staggering blow to British prestige. With his rear secured, Rommel was free to concentrate his army on the ultimate objective of the campaign - Alexandria, Cairo, and the Nile. But his army was badly depleted from the previous month's fighting. Many of the panzers were broken down or disabled across the wide expanse of the desert battlefield. His men had already gone about as far as any commander could have expected. Yet Rommel still had another race to run - the Race to Alamein and beyond! [Size, large]. *Designer Note: Explicit Supply is possible and if used the Axis player will get more supplies if he captures Tobruk. Selecting the option to invade Malta will result in an additional bonus supply convoy landed in Tobruk, but the Axis player requires Tobruk captured to receive it. Using VST Supply there is a Supply bonus for the Axis for capturing Tobruk.
Player Voting Stats | ||
---|---|---|
Member | Balance | Enjoyment |
Mike Bowen | Moderately Pro British | 7 |
Bayes | Moderately Pro British | 7 |
Gregor | Slightly Pro British | 8 |
onesixthsoldier | Slightly Pro Axis | 4 |
fabiominatti | Slightly Pro British | 6 |
Gaming Records | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1st Side Player | 2nd Side Player | Result | Score | ||||||
zorak | vs. | Al | Draw | 70 | 70 | ||||
giorgiobeacco | vs. | fabiominatti | British Major Victory | 126 | 14 | ||||
giorgiobeacco | vs. | onesixthsoldier | Axis Major Victory | 126 | 14 | ||||
Bayes | vs. | Gregor | Axis Major Loss | 14 | 126 | ||||
barnacle bob | vs. | Gray Nemesis | Axis Major Victory | 126 | 14 |
My first PBEM game in the series and a very good experience. Playing the British was forgiving for some of the first mistakes. That the opponent also landed on Malta further enhanced my possibilities. Speed in the German attacks seems to be the key in this scenario. I felt I had no possibilities to defend myself for the first part of the game, but I just managed to stabilize a front at MM and then all turned to the worse for the Germans and they expended the rest of their supplies trying to crack that line...
The British retreat to the El Alamein defensive line after the Axis offensive
This is for the pre-WDS v4.00 upgrade so may no longer be that relevant. Tobruk fell about as quickly as I thought it would. I chose to invade Malta which turned out to be a waste of time. The bunkers were just too powerful - and overrated in my opinion - for my relatively weak Italian units. Artillery had no effect on them. This also proved to be the case when I tried to take Mersa Matruh. Even with better Germans units and heavy AT guns I could barely make a dent in the bunker. Still an enjoyable game although I was still a long way from El Alamein by the end of the game.