430320_01a: Flanking the Mareth Line [HTH] - PzC 20 Tunisia 43
7 - 2 - 9
Rating: | 7.01 (14) |
Games Played: | 18 |
SM: | 5 |
Turns: | 64 |
Type: | Stock |
First Side: | Allies |
Second Side: | Axis |
Medenine, March 20th 1943: By late March, Montgomery had built up sufficient supplies to launch a strike at the Mareth Line. This was a system of fortifications built by the French between the towns of Medenine and Gabès in southern Tunisia, prior to World War II. It was designed to defend against attacks from the Italians in Libya but, following the Fall of France and Operation Torch, it fell into Axis hands and was used by the Italians and Germans to defend against the British instead. Monty's 8th Army began Operation Pugilist on March 20th with the objective of destroying the enemy now opposing Eighth Army in the Mareth position, and then to advance and capture Sfax. Pugilist itself was indecisive and failed to make a decisive breakthrough. It did, however, establish an alternative route of attack and thus laid the ground for Supercharge II, an outflanking manoeuvre via the Tebaga Gap. Here Monty sent a reinforced Command centered on Freyberg's New Zealand Division in an end around run on the old Fortified position. The New Zealanders engaged the enemy in the Tebaga Gap on March 21st, but progress over the next four days against the determined defence of German 164th Light and 21st Panzer Divisions was very slow, although the entrance to the gap was secured. [Size, large] Designer Note: This scenario has been designed for HTH.
Player Voting Stats | ||
---|---|---|
Member | Balance | Enjoyment |
Barbarrossa. | Slightly Pro Allies | 8 |
burroughs | Well Balanced | 10 |
Liquid_Sky | Slightly Pro Allies | 6 |
fabiominatti | Totally Pro Axis | 7 |
timshin42 | Well Balanced | 10 |
Gaming Records | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1st Side Player | 2nd Side Player | Result | Score | ||||||
LEGXXIIPRPF | vs. | LordDeadwood | Axis Major Victory | 90 | 10 | ||||
Oldman | vs. | crazyivan | Allies Minor Loss | 30 | 70 | ||||
The_General | vs. | Outlaw Josey Wales | Axis Minor Victory | 70 | 30 | ||||
Landser34 | vs. | PK Powers | Axis Minor Loss | 30 | 70 | ||||
giorgiobeacco | vs. | fabiominatti | Axis Major Victory | 90 | 10 |
Can't say that much, the operation never developed into a full-fledged campaign.
Allies patient and methodical operation wore down a strong Axis defense.
"Artillerymen believe the world consists of two kinds of people: other artillerymen and targets."
Set piece World War 1 style siege combat against multiple trench networks makes for a long and uninteresting game. Slightly Pro Axis since Germans and Italians have lots of entrenched and heavily fortified positions to construct their defenses. Allies will suffer heavy losses trying to push through the Axis defenses. Against equal skilled players, a stalemate should be the expected outcome. Not a favorite Tunisia '43 scenario.
Regards, Mike / "A good plan violently executed now is better than a perfect plan executed next week." - George S. Patton /
very nice scenario, with a lot of manuver
A very interesting scenario. Axis' main line of defense is quite strong, but vulnerable to flank attacks. The allied flanking column is quite strong (especially NZ units) so eventually the Axis have to retreat. If they manage to do it in an organized manner, they have a chance of winning.
Interesting scenario. Allied units released piecemeal makes it easier for the Axis to choose where to counter the Allied attack. Weather and terrain play a big role.